For over long years, we have diligently conducted independent research and product testing. When you make a purchase through our links, we may earn a commission.

Top Picks for Your First Ride: The Ultimate Guide to Best First Cars

Art Reynolds, Senior Writer

Published:

Best beginner bicycles buying guide illustration

6 min read

Contents:

    Buying your first car is a rite of passage, a step into greater freedom and responsibility. If this is your journey’s beginning, choosing the right car can seem daunting amidst a sea of options. In this ultimate guide to the best first cars, we’ll simplify your decision-making process, ensuring you find a vehicle that’s not just a means of transport, but a trustworthy companion for your road ahead.

    From reliability to affordability, safety features to fuel economy, we know you’re seeking a balance in your first automotive investment. So, whether you’re a new driver, a parent scouting for a safe option for your teen, or simply someone on the hunt for a practical first purchase, we’ve got you covered.

    Understanding What Makes a Great First Car

    Before we dive into the specifics, let us underline the attributes that typically make a car ideal for first-time owners.

    Reliability – A Non-Negotiable Feature

    Your first foray into car ownership should be stress-free. A reliable car means fewer repairs, less maintenance, and more road-time. Look for makes and models with a proven track record.

    Affordability – Keeping it Pocket-Friendly

    The cost doesn’t end at the price tag. Insurance, fuel, and upkeep play substantial roles in the long-term cost of a car. Our best first cars picks are budget-conscious without compromising on quality.

    Safety – Your Top Priority

    We’ve specifically chosen cars that have excellent safety ratings. Safety features like airbags, antilock brakes, and recent advancements like electronic stability control are not just perks – they’re essential.

    Fuel Economy – Save Money and the Planet

    Especially for those with lengthy commutes or the environmentally conscious, a first car with good mileage is key. Cars that sip gently on the fuel help keep your wallet and the earth happy.

    Resale Value – Looking Ahead

    Eventually, you’ll sell your first car. High depreciation can gouge the value of a new car, so we chose cars known to hold their value over time.

    Best Compact Cars for First-Time Drivers

    Compact cars are a fantastic option due to their ease of handling and parking, great fuel efficiency, and affordability. Here are the picks that stand out in the compact category:

    The Ideal City Companion – Honda Civic

    • Reliability: Renowned for its endurance and minimal maintenance.
    • Safety: Continuously scoring high on safety tests.
    • Fuel Economy: Averages an impressive 32-36 MPG.
    • Resale Value: The Civic holds its value admirably, a boon for future trades.

    Perfect for the Urban Explorer – Mazda3

    • Engaging Drive: A sporty feel that doesn’t compromise on safety.
    • Solid Safety Features: It comes with smart city brake support and blind-spot monitoring.
    • Fuel Economy: Expect around 26-35 MPG, making it both fun and frugal.
    • Affordability: Competitive pricing with a premium feel.

    Best Midsize Cars for the Comfort-Seeking Driver

    For those who desire a little more room and comfort, midsize cars are the sweet spot delivering spacious interiors and a smoother ride.

    The Dependable Choice – Toyota Camry

    • Reliability: The Camry is almost synonymous with dependability.
    • Comfort: Spacious interiors with ergonomically designed seats.
    • Safety: Toyota Safety Sense is a suite of advanced active safety features.
    • Fuel Economy: Delivers an average of 28-39 MPG.

    The Smart Traveler’s Pick – Honda Accord

    • Roomy Interior: Ample space that sets a high bar in its class.
    • Safety: Strong safety scores coupled with innovative technology.
    • Fuel Economy: Averages 30-38 MPG with a blend of power and efficiency.
    • Resale Value: Like the Civic, the Accord is a wise investment that holds its worth.

    Best SUVs for Adventurous First-Time Buyers

    For the adventure-seekers who need a vehicle to match their lifestyle, SUVs offer space, capability, and versatility. These are top picks that don’t intimidate a new driver.

    The Compact Powerhouse – Subaru Crosstrek

    • All-Wheel Drive: Standard on all models, offering better traction in varying conditions.
    • Build Quality: Durable and ready for rougher roads.
    • Safety: Subaru’s EyeSight Driver Assist Technology is a highlight for safety-conscious buyers.
    • Fuel Economy: Respectable for its class at around 22-29 MPG.

    The Family-Friendly SUV – Honda CR-V

    • Space: Ample cargo room and a spacious backseat for family and friends.
    • Safety: Consistently high safety ratings and reliable driver aids.
    • Fuel Economy: Efficient for its size, ranging from 28-34 MPG.
    • Resale Value: Maintains value similar to its sedan siblings.

    Most Economical Choices for Cost-Conscious Purchasers

    The Budget-Friendly Steer – Hyundai Accent

    • Price: Often the most affordable option in its class.
    • Warranty: Hyundai’s warranty is one of the best, offering peace of mind.
    • Fuel Economy: Stretch your dollars with up to 29-39 MPG.
    • Cost of Ownership: Low insurance rates and maintenance costs.

    The High-Efficiency Leader – Toyota Prius

    • Hybrid Technology: A pioneer in hybrids providing exceptional fuel savings.
    • Low Emissions: Great for those looking to reduce their carbon footprint.
    • Reliability: The Prius has a reputation for longevity and low running costs.
    • Resale Value: Excellent for a hybrid, partly due to its iconic status.

    Best Luxury Options for the Aspiring Connoisseur

    Even newcomers may seek a slice of luxury. These options offer a taste of the high life without being impractical.

    The Compact Luxury Marvel – Audi A3

    • Sophisticated Design: An entry-level luxury car that doesn’t look entry-level.
    • Advanced Tech: Equipped with state-of-the-art technology and premium features.
    • Performance: Agile handling with an emphasis on drive comfort.
    • Resale Value: Performs well in retaining its value over time, despite being a luxury car.

    The Entry-Level Elegance – Mercedes-Benz A-Class

    • High-End Feel: The smallest offering from Mercedes-Benz still comes packed with luxury.
    • Tech Features: Infotainment and safety tech often found in more expensive models.
    • Fuel Economy: Competitive within the luxury segment.
    • Compact Size: Ideal for city driving and ease of parking.

    Cars to Avoid for First-Time Buyers

    It’s just as important to know what to stay away from as it is to know what to target. Here are some types that first-time buyers may want to reconsider:

    Oversized SUVs and Trucks

    • Handling Difficulty: Large vehicles can be challenging to maneuver for inexperienced drivers.
    • Costly: Higher fuel consumption and insurance costs.

    High-Performance Sports Cars

    • Safety Risks: Powerful engines can be tempting for risky driving behaviors.
    • Insurance Premiums: Expect to pay a hefty sum to insure a sporty car as a new driver.

    Cars with Poor Safety Ratings

    • No compromise should be made on safety, so always check for up-to-date safety ratings.

    Conclusion: Your First Car is a Milestone, Choose Wisely

    Selecting your first car is about more than four wheels and an engine – it’s about finding a reliable, safe, and enjoyable extension of your independence. The best first cars embody these principles, promising not only a solid start to your driving journey but an experience that enriches your life.

    Whether it’s the compact efficiency of a Honda Civic, the adventurous spirit of a Subaru Crosstrek, or the refined pleasure of an Audi A3, your choice should reflect your needs and aspirations. Stick with vehicles known for their reliability, safety, affordability, fuel economy, and resale value.

    Remember, a car purchase is significant, but it’s also the beginning of a learning process. Take your time, do your research, and make a decision that feels right. Your first car will set the tone for your future on the road, so make it count.

    Art Reynolds, Senior Writer
    Art Reynolds

    Art Reynolds is a Senior Writer and a leading authority in the field of cars. With years of experience and